Just put a random video over the guys reaction it will be hilarious
Theatre scene from spiderman
Cat squishing another cat
“Pocket sand!” Meme template
Big Guy Ordering at McDonald's
A transparent Alastor monocle.
It's a worried pennywise. I recently used this in a meme to mashup the TMNT and It. If you need any ideas i have a feeling this could be a good template for if some sort of monster is worried like "when Mothman tries to attack you but you have a lamp".